Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita (comparative study)
by Ranjni M. | 2013 | 54,094 words
This page relates ‘The Krama school of philosophy� of study dealing with Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of two non-dualistic philosophies, Pratyabhijna from Kashmir and Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta from Kerala, highlighting their socio-cultural backgrounds and philosophical similarities..
Go directly to: Footnotes.
4.1. The Krama school of philosophy
Krama is a Tāntric school independently existed in Kashmir Ś, but later it included in the Trika. The meaning of the term Krama includes sequencing and it is said that the realization happens only through successive stages. In this system worship is done to Śپ, the Goddess, and the Śāktopāya or the path of knowledge of Śپ is considered as the best to attain the goal. For the realization of the absolute, the individual should attain the knowledge of the true nature of the Cakras.
Krama system admits ī or ʲ ṃv as the highest reality. So it bears names like īnaya, Devīnaya, ѲԲⲹ or Mahārthadarśana.[1] It is also called Auttarānaya because it started in Kashmir, the ٳٲīṻ.[2] This system is based on Āgamic literature.
Some of the Ā depended by the system are:
- 屹,
- Kramasiddhi,
- 峾,
- ղԳٰᲹٳ첹
Abhinavagupta’s ղԳٰǰ첹 made the doctrines of Krama system very clear.[3] The study of K.C.Pandey made it clearer and he proclaimed that the propagator of the system is ŚԲԻ岹, also called Avatārakanātha.[4] Eraka was another teacher who was the grand-pupil of ŚԲԻ岹. Hrasvanātha and dzᲹ are other earlier teachers of Krama system.
Well-known works belonged to this system are:
- ūٰ,
- Kramodaya,
- ʲñśپ첹,
- śپ첹,
- Kramastotra,
- ѲԲⲹprakāśa, etc.
According to Krama system, ī is the ultimate principle, performing five functions ṣe貹, ñԲ, ʰṅkԲ, Gati and 岹. �Kala� to throw, ‘Kala� to go or to know (kala gatau), ‘Kala� to count (kala saṅkhyāne) and ‘Kala� to sound (kala śabde) are different meanings of the root word Kala of ī.
Her functions are:
1. that eternally manifests what lies within (Kśepa)
2. that grasps what is so manifested as identical with itself (ñԲ)
3. that marks out the manifested as distinct from one another as it is this and not-this (ʰṅkԲ)
4. that manifested as related to itself much in the same manner as the reflection is to the reflecting surface such as mirror etc.(Gati)
5. that brings about the disappearance of all that is manifested and shines in its true original form as pure self-consciousness (岹).[5]
Due to the manifestation of the objects and transcends time, ī gets the name ṛs屹 and ṅkṣiṇ�. The concept of twelve forms of ī occupies an important place in Krama.[6] They are related to the knower, known and the means of knowledge.
Twelve forms are:
- Śṛṣṭiī,
- 鲹ٲī,
- ٳپśī,
- ۲ī,
- ṃhī,
- ṛtܰī,
- ܻī,
- ṇḍī,
- ʲ첹ī,
- Բܻī,
- Ѳī,
- ѲṇḍDzǰī.
The empirical world is the grossification of ṃv, the universal conscious energy, through obscuration or concealment of its essential nature.[7] According to the difference of capacities and tendencies of the individuals the means for liberation differ. The realization of the true nature of the sense organs and the true knowledge of the empirical world are some means to liberation.[8] Initially the Krama system belonged to a group in which ʰٲⲹñ also included. Both have the same Ā base and monistic nature.
Footnotes and references:
[2]:
Pandey, K.C., Abhinavagupta, p. 463.
[3]:
ղԳٰǰ첹, 3.197.
[4]:
Pandey, K.C, Abhinavagupta, p. 471.
[5]:
ղԳٰǰ첹, 3.203-205; Also Vide Pandey, K.C., Abhinavagupta, pp. 504-505.
[6]:
Sarma, L.N., Kashmir Ś, P. 58.
[7]:
Pandey, K.C., Abhinavagupta, p. 539.
[8]:
Ibid., p. 538f. Abhinavagupta has given a detail description of the system in his ղԳٰǰ첹 and the same has been highlighted by K.C.Pandey in his voluminous work Abhinavagupta, pp. 461-541. For further details of the system also vide Navjivan Rastogi’s monumental work, The Krama Tantricism of Kashmir, Motilal Banarsidass Publishers, Delhi, 1979.