Principle of Shakti in Kashmir Shaivism (Study)
by Nirmala V. | 2016 | 65,229 words
This page relates ‘Conclusion� of the thesis dealing with the evolution and role of Shakti—the feminine principle—within the religious and philosophical framework of Kashmir Shaivism. Tantrism represents an ancient Indian spiritual system with Shakti traditionally holding a prominent role. This study examines four major sub-streams: Kula, Krama, Spanda, and Pratyabhijnā.
Chapter 7 - Conclusion
Tantrism is the archaic cultic system which gave much prominence to the female principle. Internal and external evidences affirm that Śپ was a vital and inevitable principle in almost all early streams of Tantrism. In all the prominent streams of Kashmir Ś too Śپ is a crucial constituent of their epistemology. References to Śپ as feminine principle in the form of power-provider of the deities are available in Vedic literature also. The investigation about the origin of the term Śپ leads one back to a broader linguistic domain, instead of convincingly admitting the theory of its Vedic emergence. The only available discussion in this topic is of Rosa Ronzitti who provides much clearer way to find out the pre-Vedic roots of the Śپ. The terminologies-that show similarities with Śپ-which are taken from other early languages do not provide any assistance in favour of the feminine aspect of the corresponding concept. Hence the present study attempted to associate the origin and development of the term with the ancient Egyptian language. A close examination of the connotation and representation of the Egyptian term ‘Isis� (later on developed to the Greek ‘Ischees�) with which the term Śپ bears close linguistic association, evidently points out the ‘feminine power�.
As regards to the monistic Ś of Kashmir, Śپ, the essential principal of the doctrine having an obvious feminine nature, has been undergoing noticeable changes in its history. The very concept of Śپ which in the early times was placed atop its philosophic structure gradually has lost its prominence. Even though there are numerous Śپs exclusive to the monistic Ś of Kashmir, the pentadic and triadic forms are treated here as inclusive of all the other varieties. Nature of these types of Śپs suggests the subordinate position of Śپ in the developed philosophy of Kashmir Ś.
The prominence of Śپ has thus been changing constantly in all the sub-streams of Kashmir Ś. This evolution happened to the Śپ was through the four major sub-systems viz., Kula, Krama, Spanda and ʰٲⲹñ. Kula, the earliest cultic tradition, is popularly identified for its Śپ-orientation. Regarding its earliest origin of Śپ, the present study deviates from the traditional accounts and proposes an observation that Kula is a re-emergence of the cult of archaic mother goddess worship prevailed once all over the world. It is assumed thus because of the Śaivite traditions like śܱ貹ٲ and 첹 flourished around the first century CE, which exhibit the features of both Tantric and Vedic religions. In fact it was the foremost attempt of Brāhmaṇic domestication of Tantra. But 첹 system of Śaivite school, which could not survive effectively for long period, kept aloof itself for retaining of the previous cultic or Tantric peculiarities such as the centrality of feminine principle and later it sustained through the new system named Kula.
Even though the earliest sources of Kula system available at present do not offer unsophisticated ritualistic form of the basic Kula, the developed metaphysical principles expressed in them are centered on Śپ. The main aim of the ritualistic practices in Kula is the attainment of supernatural powers. In this scheme, the practitioners, teachers and those who attain the powers are known as ۴Dzī. According to the level of powers they have, ۴Dzī are of different types such as ī, Gocarī and Dikcarī. Among these, ī is one who acquired the power to travel in the sky. The state of ī is called Khecaratva, the highest level of supernatural power to be attained by the contemplators. The very concept of Khecaratva has been viewed as an archetype of the concept of ٲԳٰⲹ-a much more progressive philosophical idea of later time.
In the subsequent phase of Kula, the origination of more philosophical ideas that assure the prominence of Śپ is found. The cultic model of Śپ here evolved into the alphabet goddesses called ī and ṛk. ʲ, 貹 and ʲparā are the visual identities of Śپ in Kula.
Krama system, originated from Kula propounds the ultimate principle as ī or ṅkṣiṇ�. The supreme principle here indicates the time which controls birth, sustenance and death. Some internal contemplative practices lead the practitioner to the ultimate Śپ. The concept of Śپcakra consisted of īs is comparatively more philosophical one.
The subsequent tradition, Spanda has a visible layer which intended to establish the supreme consciousness, Ś; and has an inner layer which inwardly ardent to Śپ. Finally, ʰٲⲹñ perceives Śپ as the nature of Ś, as identical to Ś and as subordinate to Ś.
A perusal of the fundamental textual sources explicitly says that the remarkable changes happened to the principle of Śپ in different sects of Kashmir Ś were the effects of significant social transformations that took place in their respective historical period. It can be learnt from the evidences scattered in the authentic treatises that make deliberate efforts to transport Brāhmaṇical notions into Tantrism was transformed the peculiar characteristics of the latter. This led the mainstream orthodoxy and its philosophy to internalize, purify and moralize the Tantras in accordance with their own worldview. As the fundamental perspective of Brāhmaṇism was deeply rooted in patriarchal mindset, it induced the necessity of the establishment of an omnipotent masculine principle instead of the feminine-centered doctrines of Tantrism. This ultimately ended in a process which can categorically be called De-Śāktisation in the realm of Kashmir Ś.
De-Śāktisation tendencies are not a matter of early medieval or medieval age alone as it did not confine to the writers and practitioners of bygone centuries. Modern scholars who are regularly engaged with the studies and analysis of diverse concepts of Tantrism also seem to have been following a strong inclination towards this framework of Brāhmaṇic orthodoxy.
The Śپ-centered conceptions and connotations got disoriented from their actual feminine characters through extortion and expansion, and the principles with masculine identities viz., Akula, Anuttara, Bhairava, Cakreśa etc. were placed upon them. This resulted in the germination of numerous sub-schools and their own literary works within the sphere of Kula and Krama systems. Various processes such as giving new interpretation and interpolations to existing treatises, formation of new works, formulation of new sub-sects and also amalgamation of ritual practices, which has precisely been termed by Arindam Chakrabarthy as “the relentless play of hermeneutical imagination�, were resorted to fulfill this goal.
Kashmir Ś in its zenith had displayed an enormous religious-philosophic nature. The reason for this is the amalgamation of various elements of religion and philosophy made by the Kashmirian polymath Abhinavagupta. The fundamental concepts which support such amalgamated highly esoteric philosophy do appear as the manifestations of the concept of Śپ. These Śپ oriented concepts highlighted the religious and philosophical prominence of the non-dual Ś in the later period. It suggests that the divergent roles of Śپ-including the linguistic, aesthetic, gnostic and categorical aspects-in the aforesaid domain could be viewed as the patterns of structural replication.
The main observations and findings arrived at through this study are highlighted as follows.
Observations and Findings
· The Tantric non-dualistic philosophy originated in early medieval Kashmir known which is Kashmir Śaivsim is one of the most significant schools of Śaivite Tantra and it has four major sub-streams viz., Kula, Krama, Spanda and ʰٲⲹñ.
· The feminine principle called Śپ is one of the two most prominent constituent elements in Kashmir Śaivsim as is an integral part of all antique religious philosophic tradition of Tantrism.
· The references of Śپ found in the later portions of Vedas indicate the later inclusion of the same as a necessity of the time. Etymological history of the term too goes far back to the development of Vedic Sanskrit. The exploration of the feminine principle in the cosmological discussion also predates Vedas. Thus the theory of linguistic and conceptual emergence of Śپ from Vedas is untenable.
· The principle of Śپ established in ʰٲⲹñ, the fully developed later non-dualistic school of Kashmir Ś, is in a degenerated form.
· Kula is the re-emergence of the archaic mother goddess cult, because the traditions like 첹 emerged in between the primeval and Kula cults of goddess were unsuccessful in their function of propagating the Brāhmaṇic orthodox values.
· Khecaratva is a philosophically well-developed concept of Kula which exclusively verbalizes the freedom of female. It also acts as the archetype of the concept of ٲԳٰⲹ-the key metaphysical notion of ʰٲⲹñ.
· Krama is an emergent of Kula and hence is appropriate to be articulated as Kaula. In the same way the 첹 School acted as the intermediary cause of Kula.
· The epistemological interpretation of the 12 īs of the Krama stream by modern scholars as the triad called knower, knowledge and known is unacceptable, for it is a religious philosophy.
· The Buddhist Tantra which is a fusion of Śٲ Tantric and Yogic traditions is the source of the germination of the Spanda.
· Spanda is a two-layered tradition which externally is keen to the launch of Ś-the supreme consciousness, while it internally maintains the Śٲ nature.
· The interpreters of Spanda, in support of the former layer, explain Spanda meaning ‘vibrating consciousness� as ‘vibration of consciousness� and make the metamorphosis of the inherently Śٲ school into a Śaivite one.
· The earliest Kula concept of Śپ has a semi-divine nature and it successively evolved into the divinized audial and visual models. Krama treats Śپ as the controller of time i.e., ī. In spanda the prominence of Śپ is concealed in the monistic Ś-centered philosophy. Finally in ʰٲⲹñ, Śپ is a full-fledged and multifarious philosophical principle. To sum up, the principle of Śپ has undergone an evolution in all the four sub-streams of Kashmir Ś.
· This evolution of Śپ is of a negative nature as far as its prominence is concerned. This assertion inspires to re-imagine the history and categorization of the streams of Kashmir Ś.
· It was the post scriptural authors like dzԲԻ岹 who made effective changes in the concept of Śپ and pushed the very principle aside to a subordinate position. Such an attempt with an aim to generate a masculine-centred non-dual philosophy of Tantrism was necessitated by the rise of Advaita philosophy of Śṅk
· The society existed then formed with the anti-feminine and anti-Tantric-ritualistic thoughts, was the prime cause of the evolution of the Śپ principle.
· The entire after effects of the evolution of Śپ are conceived here as ‘De-Śāktisation�-the process that committed to the establishment of the supreme masculine, by disintegrating the prominence of Śپ.
· The de-Śāktisation took place through the divergent exegetical practices in the later phase of monistic Ś developed after the ʰٲⲹñ school. This exegetical process was executed as interpolations, formulations and interpretations. (The discussions on 屹ś, ܱⲹ and siddhi in the early work like Dzśīٲ and ٱī貹ñśپ are the interpolations. Akula, bhairava, ṛdⲹ, and anuttara are the concepts newly formulated in the later domain of Kula, for presenting the supreme reality, Ś. New sub-schools such as հܰ, Śī, and ܳ were framed through the interpretations of the earlier works and the composition of new ones).
· The system of Kashmir Ś was completely subordinated to the Brāhmaṇic orthopraxy in its later stages.
· The later exponents of Kashmir Ś including Abhinavagupta did not concede the anti-Śپ perspective of dzԲԻ岹 as such, because Śپ is an inevitable principle which helped the later phase of Kashmir Ś to become socially and philosophically popular tradition.
· The inclusion of Śپ in a variety of forms is considered as the Śٲ屹ṣkṇa (disclosure of Śپ). The expressions as Śپpāta, Śپsparśa, ṇḍī, ʰپ, and Vāc are the Śٲ屹ṣkṇa. The linguistic and aesthetic modes of Śٲ屹ṣkṇa are the ʰپ and Vāc.
The relations of the principle of Śپ with the philosophical, religious, ritualistic traditions of India and other regions of South Asia, and more importantly its association with the concept of mother goddess, make the study of the very principle a task to be carried out with greater paraphernalia. To say more specifically, there is ample scope for a comprehensive search into the manifold issues connected with the principle of Śپ in Kashmir Śaivite philosophy from a feminist and anthropological perspective which would relate it with the feminine concepts of a wider cultural context of India and the world.