Cultural Cross: Ayurveda and Modern Medicine in Primary Health Care
Journal name: Ancient Science of Life
Original article title: CULTURAL CROSS 鈥� CURRENT 鈥� TRIBAL MEDICINE AYURVEDA AND MODERN MEDICINE IN THE CONTEXT OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE: (A Balanced View)
The ANSCI is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal focused on Ayurveda and traditional medicines. It publishes original research, reviews, and literary studies linking traditional knowledge with modern science, covering disciplines like botany, ethnomedicine, pharmacology, and clinical research.
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Darshan Shankar
Ancient Science of Life:
(A quarterly multi-disciplinary scientific research journal in Ayurveda)
Full text available for: CULTURAL CROSS 鈥� CURRENT 鈥� TRIBAL MEDICINE AYURVEDA AND MODERN MEDICINE IN THE CONTEXT OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE: (A Balanced View)
Year: 1985
Copyright (license): CC BY-NC-SA
Download the PDF file of the original publication
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
The article by Darshan Shankar discusses the cultural dynamics between tribal medicine, specifically its roots in Ayurveda, and modern medical practices within the context of primary health care. Shankar reflects on the ongoing neglect of traditional health care systems in tribal areas, demonstrating that these systems, based on herbal knowledge and intricate concepts of health, have persisted for thousands of years. He argues that modern medicine often overshadows these traditions, leading to a tragic loss of cultural heritage that could provide valuable insights. The article critically assesses the interplay of time, cultural history, and the potential paths for revitalizing tribal health care practices.
The Cyclical Nature of Change in Medicine
One of the article's key concepts is the cyclical movement of time, which is subdivided into four distinct phases that characterize both natural and social evolution. The first phase represents innocence and purity, followed by one of outward growth that often results in the shedding of this initial purity. The third phase signifies decay, leading to potential rebirth or transformation. In this context, Shankar posits that tribal medicine finds itself in a state of decay, traditionally linked to Ayurveda. He emphasizes the need to trace back to the roots of tribal medicine to recover its original knowledge and practices, rather than allowing modern medicine to impose its frameworks, which could lead to a complete obliteration of the foundational elements of tribal health care.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Shankar champions a balanced and respectful dialogue between tribal practitioners and Ayurvedic experts to revitalize tribal medicine without succumbing to the dominant narratives of modern medical practices. He critiques the insistent push for modern medicine in tribal contexts, which risks cultural imperialism and undermines the potential for self-reliance. Instead of viewing tribal traditions as obsolete or weak, there is an opportunity to recognize their intrinsic value and foster a creative revival that emerges from understanding and respecting the cyclical nature of time and knowledge. By actively engaging with the roots of tribal medicine, both Ayurveda and tribal health systems can coexist and thrive in a mutually beneficial manner.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What is the significance of tribal medicine in health care?
Tribal medicine, rooted in ancient traditions and herbal practices, has existed for thousands of years. Ignoring it in modern health care planning often overlooks its potential contributions to primary health care in tribal areas.
How does the concept of time affect tribal medicine?
According to the text, tribal medicine undergoes cyclic phases of growth, decay, and renewal. Its current weakened state is not permanent; understanding its historical richness is essential for revitalization.
What is the relationship between Ayurveda and tribal medicine?
Tribal medicine is believed to have its origins in Ayurveda. Both share fundamental health concepts, and strengthening tribal practices may involve revisiting these Ayurvedic roots to restore self-reliance in health.
Why is modern medicine viewed as inappropriate for tribal contexts?
Modern medicine鈥檚 roots in different cultural and historical contexts may not suit tribal traditions. Introducing it risks cultural imperialism and undermines the essence of tribal health practices, which should instead be revitalized through their own historical foundations.
Glossary definitions and references:
Scientific and Ayurvedic Glossary list for 鈥淐ultural Cross: Ayurveda and Modern Medicine in Primary Health Care鈥�. This list explains important keywords that occur in this article and links it to the glossary for a better understanding of that concept in the context of Ayurveda and other topics.
1) Medicine:
Medicine refers to the body of knowledge and practices that are employed to maintain health and prevent, diagnose, and treat illness. The text elucidates the contrast and potential integration between traditional forms, like tribal medicine, and modern medical practices, highlighting the historical and cultural dimensions of healing.
2) Knowledge:
Knowledge is presented as a crucial element in understanding health practices. The text emphasizes the importance of recognizing traditional knowledge systems, like Ayurveda, as valid and valuable compared to modern scientific approaches. Such knowledge is seen as informed by a history and cultural context that cannot be overlooked.
3) Ayurveda (膧yurveda, Ayus-veda):
Ayurveda is portrayed as an ancient system of medicine deeply rooted in Indian tradition, emphasizing holistic health through balance in bodily systems. The text argues for its relevance in understanding and revitalizing tribal health practices, asserting that Ayurvedic principles are foundational to the local health rituals present in the tribal context.
4) Science (Scientific):
Science is described as a systematic approach to understanding natural phenomena through observation, experimentation, and evidence. The text critiques the application of modern science in tribal contexts, suggesting that it may not appreciate the nuances of traditional practices, which have their own valuable understanding derived from history and culture.
5) Veda (Ved膩):
Veda signifies knowledge and is the root word for Ayurveda, encapsulating the essence of wisdom in ancient Indian tradition. The text posits that understanding the Vedic roots of health knowledge can illuminate the path for rejuvenating tribal medicine, grounding modern health initiatives within a historical framework.
6) Reason:
Reason is presented as a distinct cognitive process that leads to analytical and rational decision-making. The text discusses how modern medicine utilizes reason while critiquing its limitations in understanding the more intuitive and emotionally rooted practices inherent in traditional tribal medicine.
7) Samhita (Sa峁僪it膩, Sa峁僪ita):
Samhita refers to a collection or compilation of texts in Ayurveda, such as 'Susruta Samhita' and 'Caraka Samhita.' These texts form the foundation of Ayurvedic knowledge, outlining medicinal practices, philosophies, and health principles that offer insights into the healing traditions that can inform modern health initiatives.
8) Desire:
Desire is described in the text as a driving force behind the human struggle for health, longevity, and wellness. It is linked to the innate human instinct to overcome decay and seek healing, thus framing health practices as responses to deeper existential wants within a cultural context.
9) Drug:
Drugs, within the context of the text, refer to medicinal substances that are often associated with the practice of modern medicine. The text suggests a need for caution in relying solely on pharmaceuticals, particularly in tribal contexts where traditional herbal remedies and holistic practices may be more appropriate.
10) Sushruta-samhita (Su艣ruta-sa峁僪it膩):
Susruta-samhita is identified as one of the classical texts of Ayurveda, attributed to the physician Susruta. It serves as an essential resource that documents surgical techniques and medical practices, and it acts as an historical anchor for current discussions about the viability of traditional medicine in contemporary health paradigms.
11) Caraka-samhita (Caraka-sa峁僪it膩):
Caraka-samhita is a primary text of Ayurvedic medicine focusing on internal medicine. It outlines various principles of diagnosis and treatment, offering a blueprint for understanding health that can be integrated with the tribal health traditions, thereby enhancing the overall efficacy of both forms of practice.
12) Transformation (Transform, Transforming):
Transformation is highlighted as a natural, cyclical process observed in all manifestations of life, including health systems. The text addresses how both tribal and Ayurvedic medicine may undergo transformation processes to adapt and survive in changing times, emphasizing the need for rejuvenation rather than mere replacement.
13) Substance:
Substance refers to the material or essence underlying health practices and medicinal formulations. The text emphasizes the relationship between physical substances, such as herbs used in Ayurveda, and their metaphorical significance in understanding health, urging a deeper exploration of what these elements represent within cultural contexts.
14) Caraka (C膩raka, C膩r膩ka):
Caraka refers to the sage credited with the 'Caraka-samhita' and represents the embodiment of Ayurvedic philosophies. The text illustrates the connection between his teachings and tribal medicine, indicating a lineage of knowledge that can provide strength and insight into revitalizing local health practices.
15) Kali (K膩l墨, K膩li, K膩岣籭):
Kali refers to the Goddess of Time in the text, symbolizing the impact of time on traditions and health practices. The mention illustrates how tribal medicine's current state is influenced by historical changes and emphasizes the cyclical nature of decay and renewal in cultural contexts.
16) Hand:
Hand symbolizes the act of healing and the manual skills involved in traditional medicine practices. The text may use this term to signify the intimate relationship practitioners have with their craft, where direct experience plays a crucial role in transmitting knowledge and healing traditions.
17) Post:
Post is represented in the context of location and temporal positioning within various practices and traditions. The text underscores the significance of locality in health care, especially in tribal settings, where practices are intertwined with the cultural and environmental specifics of a given area.
Other Science Concepts:
Discover the significance of concepts within the article: 鈥�Cultural Cross: Ayurveda and Modern Medicine in Primary Health Care鈥�. Further sources in the context of Science might help you critically compare this page with similair documents:
Cow dung, Oral tradition, Modern medicine, Ayurvedic Science, Primary health care, Tribal medicine, Traditional health care.
Concepts being referred in other categories, contexts and sources.