Essay name: Tarkabhasa of Kesava Misra (study)
Author:
Nimisha Sarma
Affiliation: Gauhati University / Department of Sanskrit
This is an English study of the Tarkabhasa of Kesava Misra: a significant work of the syncretic Nyaya-Vaisesika school of Indian philosophy widely used as a beginner's textbook in southern India and has many commentaries. This study includes an extensive overview of the Nyaya and Vaisesika philosophy, epistemology and sources of valid knowledge. It further deals with the contents and commentaries of the Tarkabhasa.
Chapter 4 - Purvabhaga of Tarkabhasa: Contents
63 (of 73)
External source: Shodhganga (Repository of Indian theses)
Download the PDF file of the original publication
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
150
as it can have no relation with them. So, a new pramaṇa should be postulated
for the cognition of abhava.
But Kesava Misra nullifies this. He says that non-existence is grasped
by sense-perception itself which is aided by a ratiocination like 'had the jar
existed here it would have been perceived just like the ground', in
combination with its non-apprehension. He answered the above objection in
this way the vyapti is to be limited to positive objects. This means that sense-
organs require connection with the objects only when they cognize positive
things and not in the case of abhāva. The cognition of abhāva takes place
through the sense-organs by 'viseṣaṇaviseṣyabhava', which is not a new
relation but only a self linking relation. It occurs in cognition of abhāva like
'here is no pot'. It satisfies all the conditions for sense-object contact and so
there is no need to postulate a new pramāṇa. Moreover, if non-apprehension is
posed as a new pramaṇa, that itself being an abhava should have another non-
apprehension for its apprehension, which in its turn will require another, and
so on. This, therefore, leads to endless regression (anavasthā) and thus the
Naiyāyika claims the advantage of laghava on his side.
3. THEORY OF VALIDITY KNOWLEDGE
The Pramanyavada (the theory of validity of knowledge) is an
important topic taken up by the different systems of Indian philosophy. The
term ‘prāmāṇya' is derived from the word 'pramāṇa' with suffix ‘ṣṇya� and
means 'the nature of a pramaṇa'. 135 It is of two types, svataḥprāmāṇya and
paratah- prāmāṇya.
135.
TS. p. 323.
