Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita (comparative study)
by Ranjni M. | 2013 | 54,094 words
This page relates ‘Non-dualistic Elements in Indian Thought� of study dealing with Pratyabhijna and Shankara’s Advaita. This thesis presents a comparative analysis of two non-dualistic philosophies, Pratyabhijna from Kashmir and Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta from Kerala, highlighting their socio-cultural backgrounds and philosophical similarities..
Go directly to: Footnotes.
3. Non-dualistic Elements in Indian Thought
The truth, as the evergreen non-dualistic element, is enquired by the philosophers since the origin of the multitude of the living beings. It is the subject not only of spiritualistic thinkers, but of the socialistic and materialistic thinkers also. All diversities are starting from the non-duality. There is nothing without a basic principle.
Betty Heimann says:
“All ideologies have rooted in a basic universal concept with a view and aim at all times. The single inventions in between are accidental or sometimes took place distinctly. This universal angle of vision does not lose.�[1]
Even though the natural substances like sun, air, fire and water have their own peculiar form and quality, these functions together to maintain life in this universe. This non dualistic element, present everywhere in the universe, might have inspired the philosophers to seek the unique truth according to their own philosophical systems.
While counting, each calculation starts with one and the other numbers are following this. Without one, there is no continuation. The spiritualistic view ultimately reaches the soul’s non-duality, even though the attributes are many in number. Ancient Greek Monist Philosophers like Thales, Anaximander and Heraclitus argued that all the reality was composed of single substance. Plotinus belonging to the Platonic tradition taught that there is a supreme, totally transcendent ‘one�, containing no division, multiplicity or distinction; beyond all categories of being and non-being. Western thinkers like David Hume, Johann Gottlieb Fichte and Arthur Schopenhauer have upheld the idea of non-dualism.[2] Now the scientists are searching for the ‘one� unique particle named as Higgs boson, which may be the elementary particle of the universe.
The Sanskrit words Eka (one), Advaya (not two), Advitīya (non-dual) and Advaita (oneness) denote the notion of unity which aims in non-duality. This idea is explicitly seen in both the Vedic and non-Vedic or Āgamic traditions of India.
The importance of oneness is expressed by several sentences of Vedic literature, e.g.
(scholars are talking differently about one and only being),
yo devānā� nāmadhā eka eva |
ta� saṃpraśna� bhuvanā yāntyanyā || [4](Though the names are different, they aim at the one and only reality)
(where the universe becomes a single nest),
īśāvāsyamida� sarvam[6]
(all this is covered by the Lord), etc.
The mythical stories, fables and didactic literature of India contain several ܲṣiٲ, which give emphasis to this idea of oneness.
For instance the well known verse of the ʲñٲԳٰ:
ⲹ� ԾᲹ� paro veti ṇa laghucetasām |
udāracaritānā� tu vasudhaiva kuṭumbakam || [7][‘It is mine�, ‘It is not mine�- this is the thought of Narrow-minded persons. Generous persons consider that the whole earth is their own family.]
Almost all philosophical systems emerged to uplift the society had a sound base on the principle of non-duality. Buddhists philosophies, various schools of ձԳٲ and Āgamic cults had a strong foundation of the idea of oneness. Depending on the 貹Ծṣa and correlating the oneness and multiplicity, Ҳḍa岹 and Srī Śṅk established and propagated the Advaitic concept of Brahman.[8] In Kashmir Ś, the one and only ʲś, the conscious beatitude and independent subject, is the core principle and the diversity of the objects exists outside is only the sensible manifestation of this unifying subject.[9]
The idea of oneness is accepted by all social and cultural reformers of the modern period also. As part of the renaissance movement and Indian independence movement, the notion of oneness is profusely used by the leaders like Swami Vivekananda, Rabindranath Tagore and Mahatma Gandhi. In Kerala, the famous social reformer Sree Narayanaguru had contributed much to unify the society by upholding the principle of oneness. He tells: ※ پ oru ٲ� oru 岹� ԳṣyԳ�[10] (one caste, one religion and one god for all human beings). The idea of oneness is imbibed by the poets of all languages. The children’s poet of Kerala, Kunjunni Master says while describing � one�, “onnāyāl nannāyi, nannāyāl onnāyi� (becoming one is becoming well, becoming well is becoming one).
Footnotes and references:
[1]:
Facets of Indian Thought, Allen & Unwin, London, 1964, p. 37.
[2]:
For details see http://www.nonduality.com/western.htm.
[4]:
Ibid., 10.82.3.
[5]:
Ѳⲹṇo貹Ծṣa, 2.3.
[6]:
Īś屹DZ貹Ծṣa, 1.
[7]:
ʲñٲԳٰ, 5.3.37. This verse is seen in ᾱٴDZ貹ś (1.3.71) and in ѲDZ貹Ծṣa (6.72) with slight difference.
[8]:
jīvo brahmaiva nāpara� | Jñānāvalīmālā, 20.
[10]:
� Jātinirṇⲹṃ,� 2, ṃpūṇaṛt첹�, Narayanagurukulam, Varkala, 2000.