Significance of Debate
Debate in various philosophical and religious contexts is characterized as a formal discussion on topics related to doctrine and ethical teachings. In Jainism, it reflects discussions on dharma and showcases knowledge, as seen in engagements by Haribhadrasuri. Vaishnavism views debate as a contentious discussion, particularly in scripture interpretations. In genres like Purana and Natyashastra, it signifies deliberation among nobles and character conflicts, respectively. Overall, debate serves as a tool for intellectual exchange, essential for testing beliefs and enhancing understanding across disciplines.
Synonyms: Discussion, Argument, Dispute, Dialogue, Contention, Deliberation, Discourse, Exchange, Controversy
In Spanish: Debate; In Dutch: Debat; In Finnish: Keskustelu; In German: Debatte; In Malay: Perbahasan; In Swedish: Debatt; In French: 顿茅产补迟
The below excerpts are indicatory and do represent direct quotations or translations. It is your responsibility to fact check each reference.
Buddhist concept of 'Debate'
In Buddhism, Debate encompasses formal discussions like the one between Saccaka and a female mendicant, and discourse between differing parties, exemplified by the interactions between brahmacarins and the Buddha, often exploring contrasting views.
From: Maha Buddhavamsa鈥擳he Great Chronicle of Buddhas
(1) A formal discussion between Saccaka and the female mendicant arranged by the Licchavi royal family, which ended in a draw.[1]
From: Maha Prajnaparamita Sastra
(1) A discourse or argument held between parties to discuss differing positions, exemplified in the interactions between the brahmacarins and the Buddha.[2]
Hindu concept of 'Debate'
In Hinduism, Debate encompasses philosophical discussions, formal arguments, and scripture disputes, serving as a platform for scholars to showcase knowledge and resolve conflicts, thus enriching spiritual discourse and character interactions in texts like Mudritakumudacandra.
From: Chaitanya Bhagavata
(1) A format used by Nimai to demonstrate His vast knowledge, challenging other scholars like Mukunda.[3] (2) This term is synonymous with the word dvandva, referring to the essence of kirtana as a contentious discussion or argument.[4]
From: Brihad Bhagavatamrita (commentary)
(1) The discussion or dispute between different scriptures or parties that prompted the involvement of the Maha-Puranas and Maha-Upanishads.[5]
From: Ramayana of Valmiki (Griffith)
(1) Debate is something that the nobles are called to, to help deliberate, according to the text.[6]
Jain concept of 'Debate'
In Jainism, Debate signifies an intellectual practice exemplified by Haribhadrasuri鈥檚 confidence and knowledge, and it serves as a formal discourse on dharma topics, as seen in Namuci's engagement efforts.
From: Trishashti Shalaka Purusha Caritra
(1) A formal discussion on a particular topic, specifically concerning the teaching of dharma, that Namuci sought to engage in.[7]
The concept of Debate in scientific sources
Debate is a skill integrating rhetoric and emotional appeal, equipping individuals to engage with differing opinions. It emphasizes listening, logical reasoning, and narrative techniques to articulate and defend one's viewpoints effectively.
From: The Malaysian Journal of Medical Sciences
(1) Debate is a skill that harnesses the components of rhetoric, ethos, pathos, and logos, training individuals to listen to opposing views and reassert their positions with logical argumentation and effective storytelling.[8]