365betÓéÀÖ

Nyayakusumanjali of Udayana (study)

by Sri Ramen Bhadra | 2014 | 37,777 words

This page relates ‘Samkhya view on Veda refuted� of the study on the Nyayakusumanjali of Udayana, who belonged to the Nyaya-Vaisheshika School of Indian philosophy and lived in the 10th century. The Nyaya-Kusumanjali is primarily concerned with proving the existence of God but also deals with various other important philosophical problems. The book is presented as an encyclopedia of Nyaya-Vaisesika doctrines.

Go directly to: Footnotes.

³§Äåṃk³ó²â²¹ view on Veda refuted

After refuting the ²ÑÄ«³¾ÄåṃsÄå position, in the same verse, Udayana also briefly criticizes the ³§Äåṃk³ó²â²¹ position. According to ³§Äåṃk³ó²â²¹, the Veda is not impersonal and it is not also the statement of God. Actually, the Veda is created by the sages like Kapila and others who through the practice of yoga have acquired supernormal powers. The Veda cannot be impersonal, because it represents only some sentences or statements. A statement can never be without a speaker. But it is also not necessary to admit God, because there is no proof for his existence. There is neither perception nor inference which can establish God. So there is no question of admitting God as the speaker. But it is also not possible for an ordinary person to be a speaker of the Veda. The Veda speaks about many things which are extraordinary and cannot be rightly known by such a person. But the sages have thoroughly practiced yoga and thereby acquired extraordinary powers through which they can understand the nature of even such things. So they can be accepted as speakers of the Veda. Thus admission of God is not necessary. As against this, Udayana says that there can be no other trustworthy person than God. Only if god is accepted as the speaker of the Veda people will have complete faith in the validity of the Veda. Moreover, if in the ³§Äåṃk³ó²â²¹ view there are many sages, all having supernormal powers, they may be the speakers of the Veda, but are they also capable of creating the world? According to ±·²âÄå²â²¹ God is not only the speaker of the Veda, but is also the almighty creator of the world. If the ³§Äåṃk³ó²â²¹ view is admitted, so many persons with supernormal powers will have to be admitted. But if God is admitted only one such person will be admitted. So in the ±·²âÄå²â²¹ view there is ±ôÄå²µ³ó²¹±¹²¹. If at all any speaker for the Veda or a creator for the world is to be admitted let there be only one God performing all the activities.[1]

Footnotes and references:

[back to top]

[1]:

Ibid.

Let's grow together!

I humbly request your help to keep doing what I do best: provide the world with unbiased sources, definitions and images. Your donation direclty influences the quality and quantity of knowledge, wisdom and spiritual insight the world is exposed to.

Let's make the world a better place together!

Like what you read? Help to become even better: