365betÓéŔÖ

Triveni Journal

1927 | 11,233,916 words

Triveni is a journal dedicated to ancient Indian culture, history, philosophy, art, spirituality, music and all sorts of literature. Triveni was founded at Madras in 1927 and since that time various authors have donated their creativity in the form of articles, covering many aspects of public life....

E. M. Forster � A Critical Survey

P. G. Krishna Murthy

“We need a vantage post, for the novel is a formidable mass, and it so amorphous–no mountain in it to climb, no Parnassus or Helicon, not even a Pisgah. It is most distinctly one of the moister areas of literature, irrigated by a hundred rills and occasionally degenerating into a swamp.�
–E. M. FORSTER

Edward Morgan Forster was born on January 1, 1879, at 8,Melcombe Place, Dorset Square, London. He attended Tonbridge School, as a day scholar and later went to King’s College, Cambridge, in 1897. It was his Cambridge association that stood him in good stead as a writer of undoubted repute. He became the Resident Honorary Fellow of the King’s in 1946 and several honorary degrees were conferred on him by many universities. He was made a Companion of Honour in 1953, another Cambridge distinction.

Forster inherited a liberal outlook of life from his parentage. His great-grandfather, Henry Thornton, was a leading banker and a member of Parliament and a leading member of the Clapham Sect known for its Evangelical preaching, philanthropy and opposition to slavery. ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s father, who died young, was an architect. Forster was left to the care of his mother and the benevolent grand-aunt, Marianne Thornton, whose biography he wrote later paying rich tributes to the great lady. ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s mother came from the Whicheloes stock who were known for their aesthetic sensibilities.

Forster wrote two volumes of short stories and four of his six novels-before the first world war. Just a decade after the publication of “A Passage to India� (1924), which is now an established classic, he wrote his first biography of his Cambridge Teacher of Classics and best friend, Goldsworthy Lowes Dickinson and it appeared in 1934 and another of his great aunt, Marianne Thornton in 1956. There were the Clark Lecturers at Cambridge, published in book, form under the title, Aspects of the Novel (1927), a masterpiece of Criticism; a Travelogue, The Hill of Devi, 1953, which was the basis for his “Passage� and two large Collections of Essays, Reviews, Letters and Broadcasts collected in the book, “The Abinger Harvest�, 1936, and “Two Cheers for Democracy�, 1951, besides the posthumous publication of his last novel, Maurice, 1971.

Forster has firmly established himself as a great writer and critic and won a niche among the distinguished British writers of this age in spite of his limited literary output. It is the distinctive features of his works that have won for him a place of eminence in the literary world of this century.

As a man, according to J. R. Ackerley, Forster has the rarest and the finest qualities. Faith in personal human relationships is central to ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s credo though he was aware of the limitations placed on their efficacy. His fiction is, in many ways, artistic glorification of his basic belief in personal relations and the consequential dilemmas they create in the way of man’s realization of this ideal, as Prof. V. A. Shahane, a noted critic of Forster, justly observes. It is rightly said that Forster is the last survivor of a cultural liberal tradition in literature. It is this tradition which is richly imbued with the passion for the arts and democratic values of life. Forster as a man and writer has displayed a hatred for what is false and smug with a characteristic modesty to any claim of greatness.

As for ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s works, his short stories, written before 1914, claim our attention to the writer’s zest for tradition and we see that some of the themes of these stories reappearing in his later works on a wide expanse. Nearly all of his short stories are didactic and much influenced by Greek mythology and ideas. He believes like the ancient Greeks that the natural passions and emotions of the body need not be shunned and the man can ennoble himself by them. Italy as in the later works continues to dominate the scene in these stories. The short stories are but a glimpse of ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s artistic excellence. It is in his novels that we see the potentialities of Forster as a creative artist.

Though Forster chose to expound his views through this literary form, he oddly notes in “Aspects of the Novel,� that “the novel tells a story”–but we know he has revealed much more, delineating characters of diverse complexities through his novels.

ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s first novel, “Where Angels Fear to Treadâ€� appeared in 1905 when he was just twenty-six. No doubt, we encounter in this novel an unsteady method and a point of view with a limited appeal. The contrast in the ways of life represented by Sawston and Italy is ably presented. There is the wit and comedy which veil fierce passions and end in acts which are almost melodramatic. There is also the search for salvation and neither Sawston nor Italy is credited with any exalted position. In pursuance of truth, snobbery–social and intellectual–is criticized in the Forsterian fashion. According to Lionel Trilling, the theme of this novel is the violent opposition between British respectability and a kind of pagan and masculine integration, “Where Angels Fear to Treadâ€� marks the initial stages of a pattern.

His next novel, published in 1907, is “The Longest Journey.â€� Forster regarded this novel with particular affection, perhaps because of its association with Cambridge and his own introduction to the civilized life. It is one of the novels by which he himself has chosen to be represented in the world’s classics. Here again in his characteristic way, Forster sets up an investigation of truth or what is real. It begins in Cambridge with a group of undergraduates discussing metaphysics. The main theme revolves round the main character, Rickie Elliot, and his collapse into unreality as represented by his wife Agnes and the public school world of Sawston and his emergence again in the light under the guidance of his Cambridge friend, Ansell, and his half-brother, Stephen. The inconstant, unsubstantial state of man’s affairs is stressed in the novel. According to James McConkey, one of the recurrent motifs of this novel is that of the fragility of human existence, the fact that, “We are all of us bubbles on an extremely rough sea.â€� ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s literary art mellowed in this novel and his rhythmic imagery found its full expression here;

“A Room with a Viewâ€�, published in 1908, was ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s third novel. It should have been placed along with his first novel, “Where Angels Fear to Treadâ€�, for it was planned as early as 1903. It is full of exquisite comedy. The women characters in particular are treated with the utmost grace and wit. The juxtaposition of truth and falsehood and art and life is present here. Italy plays a significant part again in this novel as it does in the first one. Here again rhythm appears as an aesthetic device or an accompaniment to character and plot.

“Only Connect� is the motto of his fourth novel, “Howards End�, published in 1910. Here the two worlds are represented by two families–first the two Schlegel sisters (half English and half German) and the second, the Wilcox family. Margaret and Helen Schlegel live for “culture�, for the inner life, for personal relationships. Yet they are aware of the existence of an “outer life.� The Wilcoxes, on the other side, adept at “the outer life� are unaware of the existence of any other life at all. “One interesting fact about Howards End is that it was written by 1910 and it is therefore a product of that Indian summer of Victorian liberal humanist culture which immediately preceded the first world war,� “Howards End� is usually regarded as a “modern� rather than an Edwardian or Georgian novel. This novel, according to Peter Widdowson, seems in some way, to be both an image of its own milieu and symptomatic of subsequent developments, a creation “wandering between two worlds.� It contains both an ardent affirmation of liberal humanist values and an intuition of their vulnerability–perhaps their inefficacy in the process of contemporary social change. “Howards End� written before “the world broke up� in 1914, just manages to resist the depredations of those “decivilizing� forces which Forster sensed in the modern world, and finally postulates the survival of the values be cherished.

ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s fifth novel, “A Passage to Indiaâ€� published in 1924 is his best known. It is rightly said that ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s place as one of the greatest novelists of modern times would have been firm even if he had not written any other work other than the “Passage.â€�

M. Sivarama Krishna writes in “Focusâ€� on ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s “A Passage to India”–Indian Essays in Criticism–Edited by Prof. V. A. Shahane that, “In venturing to write on A Passage to India today, one feels not only a sense of a trepidation but also a sense of cripling helplessness and this stems, curiously enough, not from the paucity but from the sheer abundance of the critical corpus available on the novel, admittedly his finest, had, for the critics, at least one quality for a myth: its inexhaustibility to critical contemplation.â€� Another pungent Indian critic of ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s Passage, Prof. Viswanadham, writes in his book, “India in English Fictionâ€� that “the novel is a plea for love: love is the Bridge of Understanding. “A Passage to Indiaâ€� is a very sensitive seismograph registering the concussions of the Indo-British world. Hence perhaps its greatest popularity and relevance today.â€�

ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s A Passage to India is a great classic because it is primarily concerned not with social or political problems, but with man and his relationship with the universe. ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s quest is for the ultimate reality or truth–as exemplified both in Mrs. Moore and Professor Godbole, the two central characters in the novel, observes Prof. V. A. Shahane, a great authority on the novelist in his “E. M. Forster–A Study in Double Vision.â€� On the surface of it the novel deals with the Indo-English relations–social and political in the British India. But it has many other facets–it is a novel of action and character and it reveals a symbolic pattern which in the view of Prof. Shahane is the heart of its structure and meaning, its design and vision. On a narrative plane, the “Passageâ€� is primarily concerned with the theme of friendship and love. In Chapter II, Aziz, another chief character of the novel, discusses with his friend as to “whether it is possible to be friends with an Englishman.â€� Thus the Aziz-Fielding relationship becomes the core of the story which unfolds the themes of separation and union, hatred and love, negation and affirmation. The problem of communication between man and man is thus central to the novel’s theme.

The “Passageâ€� has three structural dimensions, Mosque, Caves and Temple. These are three parts of the novel, in their dramatic and symbolic meanings. They converge on the central stream of the passage to India, ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s quest for truth, thus giving it an organic unity. The major mythological referent of “A Passage to Indiaâ€� is that of Hinduism and such a referent has given Forster a framework totally in keeping with the implications of his voice and that the prophecy of the novel results from such a relationship as James McConkey observes in his book “The Novels of E. M. Forster.â€�

ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s posthumously published novel, Maurice, came out in 1971 (Forster died on June 7, 1970). It has reinforced the impression of ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s rare distinction as a “special man.â€� It was on the theme of homosexuality, and Forster himself wrote in defence of the theme in a letter to Forrest Reid. Forster here idealizes the idea of green wood and even the relationship between man and man. The relationship between the main characters, Maurice and Clive, is intellectually and physically portrayed but not vitally projected, The theme is surely Lawrentian, but it lacks the vitality and the fire one finds in the fiction of D. H. Lawrence. As a novel Maurice hangs uncertainly between two great poles of ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s achievement â€� the finely cultivated architectural design of “Howards Endâ€� and the aesthetically and philosophically created structure of his masterpiece, “A Passage to India.â€� The composition was almost a psychic relief for Forster from the “state of restlessness and lack of connection between individual and societyâ€�, to quote again Prof. Shahane.

“Aspects of the Novel�, reveals a keen and individual mind, and a love of great literature which Forster is successful in communicating to the reader. Here in the introductory remarks Forster says that the human quality of the novel should be upheld. In the “Aspects�, he deals with the different aspects of the novel and the story is the foremost aspect of it.

Forster is “rareâ€� indeed because he is in part a late Victorian or an Edwardian and in part a modern but, above all, human. “His life extends over a long period from 1879-1970 marked by rapid and radical social change. It is difficult to find another British writer who has ąó´Ç°ů˛őłŮ±đ°ů’s vision and gifts and whose relationship with the age covers such varied phases of social and cultural changes for ninety years or more. It is, however, not so much this uncommon relationship with the age that makes Forster so unique as the inherent qualities of his personality, mind and art.â€�

Let's grow together!

I humbly request your help to keep doing what I do best: provide the world with unbiased sources, definitions and images. Your donation direclty influences the quality and quantity of knowledge, wisdom and spiritual insight the world is exposed to.

Let's make the world a better place together!

Like what you read? Help to become even better: